BACKGROUND: The oligometastatic paradigm suggests that some patients with a limited number of metastases might be cured if all lesions are eradicated. Evidence from randomised controlled trials to support this paradigm is scarce. We aimed to assess the effect of stereotactic ablative radiotherapy (SABR) on survival, oncological outcomes, toxicity, and quality of life in patients with a controlled primary tumour and one to five oligometastatic lesions.
METHODS: This randomised, open-label phase 2 study was done at 10 hospitals in Canada, the Netherlands, Scotland, and Australia. Patients aged 18 or older with a controlled primary tumour and one to five metastatic lesions, Eastern Cooperative Oncology Group score of 0-1, and a life expectancy of at least 6 months were eligible. After stratifying by the number of metastases (1-3 vs 4-5), we randomly assigned patients (1:2) to receive either palliative standard of care treatments alone (control group), or standard of care plus SABR to all metastatic lesions (SABR group), using a computer-generated randomisation list with permuted blocks of nine. Neither patients nor physicians were masked to treatment allocation. The primary endpoint was overall survival. We used a randomised phase 2 screening design with a two-sided a of 0·20 (wherein p<0·20 designates a positive trial). All analyses were intention to treat. This study is registered with ClinicalTrials.gov, number NCT01446744.
FINDINGS: 99 patients were randomised between Feb 10, 2012, and Aug 30, 2016. Of 99 patients, 33 (33%) were assigned to the control group and 66 (67%) to the SABR group. Two (3%) patients in the SABR group did not receive allocated treatment and withdrew from the trial; two (6%) patients in the control group also withdrew from the trial. Median follow-up was 25 months (IQR 19-54) in the control group versus 26 months (23-37) in the SABR group. Median overall survival was 28 months (95% CI 19-33) in the control group versus 41 months (26-not reached) in the SABR group (hazard ratio 0·57, 95% CI 0·30-1·10; p=0·090). Adverse events of grade 2 or worse occurred in three (9%) of 33 controls and 19 (29%) of 66 patients in the SABR group (p=0·026), an absolute increase of 20% (95% CI 5-34). Treatment-related deaths occurred in three (4·5%) of 66 patients after SABR, compared with none in the control group.
INTERPRETATION: SABR was associated with an improvement in overall survival, meeting the primary endpoint of this trial, but three (4·5%) of 66 patients in the SABR group had treatment-related death. Phase 3 trials are needed to conclusively show an overall survival benefit, and to determine the maximum number of metastatic lesions wherein SABR provides a benefit.
FUNDING: Ontario Institute for Cancer Research and London Regional Cancer Program Catalyst Grant.
The Vancouver Rapid Access (VARA) clinic was designed to provide palliative radiotherapy and holistic care to patients with incurable lung cancer. Analysis of the pilot phase demonstrated improved radiotherapy wait-times and access to supportive services compared to standard practice. This study aims to prospectively assess the impact of the clinic on patient reported symptoms and quality of life. Patient assessments are completed at baseline and by a telephone follow up four-weeks later using Likert scales adapted from the Edmonton Symptom Assessment System (scale 0–10) and European Organization for Research and Treatment of Cancer questionnaires (scale 1–4). Patient reported outcomes at follow-up are compared to baseline using wilcoxon signed-rank test for categorical variables and paired sample t-test for continuous variables. Baseline data was collected on 125 patients, 109 received palliative radiotherapy (87%). At the 4 week follow up, 22 patients had died. Seventy-one of the remaining 103 patients completed the follow-up questionnaire, resulting in a 69% response rate among survivors. The mean patient reported overall health score, improved from 4.8 to 6.1 (p<0.01). All respiratory symptoms except chest pain (p=0.06) were associated with a statistically significant improvement after the clinic, whereas all respiratory symptoms improved post radiotherapy. Mean bone pain scores decreased from 5.5 to 2.7 (p<0.01). Assessment of symptoms secondary to brain metastases is limited by small patient numbers. The VARA clinic provides timely access to palliative radiotherapy and supportive services resulting in improved patient reported outcomes. Despite a high symptom and disease burden, patients report improved overall health and palliation of respiratory symptoms and bony pain. The studies completed on the VARA clinic to date, continue to support its value in our center.